A young girl, along with four other kids, approached me while I was waiting for an ikot jeepney in front of UPD Cooperative store. "Kuya, pahingi ng barya (can I ask for some change?)," she said expectant. I looked at her and shaked my head. I couldn't talk because I was eating a Mister Donut Croissant. "Pahingi na lang ng kinakain mo (why not give me some of what you're eating?)," she rudely replied back. Again, she asked one more time and added, "sige na, malaki naman yan (c'mon, it's a big piece anyway)." For a moment there, I found myself unable to reply.
Well, if this is your first meal of the day at 4pm, it's barely enough for me. That's what I wanted to reply, but I chose not to say it. Instead, I gave her another shake in the head. If she had been more polite, I would have probably given her a share of the food. I've no qualm with that. However, the moment she approached me and started talking rudely, that's when I thought that she was doing it not because she was hungry. She was doing it for the heck of it. You could tell from the way she looked and talked. After trying out her tactic on me, she walked to an elderly woman and asked for change. "Nasaan ang mga nanay niyo? (Where are your mothers?), the elderly woman asked. Instead of answering, the girl and her friends just giggled and laughed. It was quite disrespectful.
I've seen a quite number of kids asking for alms. Every time it happens, I'm confronted with a dilemma: should I give and reinforce their behavior or should I not?
Back in my undergraduate, a psychology professor once remarked that if we gave alms to these kids it would become a positive reinforcement for them. They'd think that it is the way life goes. Ask, and you shall be given. However, in one class in humanities, I watched this documentary about 2 orphan, homeless and poor kids trying to survive in the harsh outside world by asking for alms. If they really had no choice, they end up stealing and once caught are sent to jail alongside adult offenders. Only a few street children survive in such harsh conditions (inside or outside the jails).
By giving, I know it would alleviate their suffering momentarily. However, it does not solve the problem. By not giving, I know that they might die of hunger or end up in a jail for stealing. Either way, the consequences are not at all pleasing.
(To be continued...)